Review of Reaganland by Rick Perlstein

Rick Perlstein’s Reaganland: America's Right Turn marks a fascinating continuation of his exploration into American political history. Having previously read Perlstein's Nixonland, I found the stylistic and tonal shifts in Reaganland to be quite pronounced. However, the book remains replete with the wide-ranging and meticulously researched evidence that characterizes Perlstein's work, showcasing his deep cultural understanding and the intricate ways in which culture, politics, and history intersect.

One of the most striking aspects of Reaganland is its organization and evocative detail, particularly in its depiction of the rise of the Moral Majority. Perlstein expertly traces the development of the religious right's political awareness and sophistication, which emerged as a powerful force in response to the social upheavals of the 1960s and the Civil Rights Movement. This transition is explored with a depth and clarity that makes the complex historical narrative accessible and compelling.

Perlstein's analysis of Ronald Reagan himself is particularly noteworthy. Through illustrative examples and detailed evidence, he dispels the myth of Reagan as a political simpleton or puppet. Instead, Reagan is portrayed as a politician with remarkable acumen, a keen sense of timing, and exceptional communication skills. Perlstein effectively argues that while Reagan may not have been deeply concerned with policy minutiae, he was an astute and effective advocate for his political goals and agenda.

Despite its length, Reaganland captivates with its rich, thoughtful analysis. The book does not aim to provide a testable roadmap for its claims, and Perlstein's argument can sometimes feel muted. However, this approach suits the book's intent as a cultural and historical text, designed to weave disparate events into a coherent narrative. The narrative convincingly portrays America’s shift towards conservatism in the wake of the 1960s and 1970s, illustrating the breakdown of the New Deal coalition and the rise of a new political era.

Perlstein’s work can be seen as reflecting elements of the scholarship of Stephen Skowronek, particularly regarding the cyclical nature of political regimes and their influence on the presidency. Reaganland thus provides a comprehensive and thoughtful analysis of the political landscape during Reagan's rise, making it an invaluable resource for anyone interested in understanding this pivotal era in American politics.

Reaganland is a richly detailed and insightful text that offers a nuanced analysis of the rise of the Moral Majority and the Reagan Revolution. Perlstein's ability to connect wide-ranging events into a coherent and vivid timeline makes the book a compelling read for those interested in the cultural and political shifts of late 20th-century America.